Library and Archives Canada
Symbol of the Government of Canada

Institutional links

Print of an imaginary view of Canada, [1528]
1ère vue de Canada (First View of Canada), [1528]. Notice anything odd?
Source
Print of an imaginary scene of beaver-hunting in Canada, circa 1782
Beaver Hunting in Canada,
circa 1782
Source

ARCHIVED - Detecting the Truth.
Fakes, Forgeries and Trickery

Archived Content

This archived Web page remains online for reference, research or recordkeeping purposes. This page will not be altered or updated. Web pages that are archived on the Internet are not subject to the Government of Canada Web Standards. As per the Communications Policy of the Government of Canada, you can request alternate formats of this page on the Contact Us page.

Postal Impostors

Philatelists are stamp collectors. The more serious philatelists are willing to pay great sums of money to add a rare stamp to their collection. Of course, when people are willing to spend a lot of money for something, there are always dishonest and greedy people trying to trick them -- even if it means going to jail if they're caught!

The first postage stamp was issued in Great Britain in 1840 (1851 in Canada). Twenty years later, the first postage stamp forgery -- a stamp created to fool philatelists into thinking that it is a genuine one -- appeared on the market. Some forgeries are easy to spot while others are dangerously good copies.

Here are two examples of forged stamps that Library and Archives Canada has in its collection:

Postage stamp of Queen Victoria, from Prince Edward Island, June 1, 1870 Forged postage stamp from Prince Edward Island, after June 1, 1870

Postage stamp of Queen Victoria, from Prince Edward Island, June 1, 1870
Source

Here are the genuine and the forged Prince Edward Island stamps. You can probably tell which one is the real one, and which one is the fake.

The genuine stamp is engraved. This makes Queen Victoria's picture sharper. The forged stamp is a poor lithograph version of the portrait, that looks quite fuzzy.

Counterfeit postage stamp of Queen Victoria, from Vancouver Island, [1942]

Counterfeit 5-cent postage stamp of Queen Victoria, from Vancouver Island, [1942]
Source


Postage stamp of Queen Victoria, from Vancouver Island, Septemeber 19, 1865

5-cent postage stamp of Queen Victoria, from Vancouver Island, September 19, 1865
Source

The funny thing about this particular stamp is that the forgery is more valuable than the genuine stamp! When Prince Edward Island became a Canadian province in 1873, it sold off all of its remaining stamps at a much discounted price. This meant that over 1.5 million really cheap stamps suddenly flooded the market. Since these stamps had next to no value, forgers had no reason to make copies. And since the forged stamps are harder to find than the original, it's the forgeries that are more valuable!

Now, let's look at the work of a master forger, Jean de Sperati. He made stamp forgery his life's work. He got so good at it that his creations were just as good (and some say even better) than the real stamps. This is the case with the Vancouver Island forgery. The original stamp was issued in 1865. To make his forgery, de Sperati bleached a real, cheaper stamp from that same era. He then used a process called photolithography to make an almost perfect copy of the stamp. If you look very (and I mean very) closely at the forged stamp, you may notice a slight weakness in the bottom frame line, just below the letter "N" in "cents." There is also a small white area on the upper lip of the Queen, and the tiny lines" around her mouth and nose are a little coarser. The cancellation mark is also a forgery.

In his lifetime, Jean de Sperati forged over 500 stamps. He sometimes signed his work in pencil on the back. By 1942, de Sperati was famous and his forged stamps are often worth more than the originals.

Did you know…?

Secret images are hidden in stamps.

Explore this topic


Glossary

engraved: cut in a hard surface such as stone or metal

lithography: a printing method on paper where the design is drawn on a limestone or a metal plate with a greasy ink

photolithography: a printing method on paper, like lithography, except that the design is photographed instead of drawn